It would be silly to sum up the entire Caribbean region with any kind of overarching description. Each island has a unique character and culture of its own, distinct scenery and attractions. Even the beaches are different, ranging from the quintessential soft white sand of Aruba, to the unexpected pink ones and rocky coves of Curacao.
If it’s been impossible for you to choose which island to visit, I don’t blame you! To be honest, each of them sound like an absolute dream in their own right. To help you decide, here’s a breakdown of the 14 best Caribbean islands to visit, with everything that makes each one special:
1. Aruba
Aruba has everything that makes a Caribbean island a beach lover’s dream: white sand so soft you don’t need to wear sandals; calm, baby-blue water; and hospitable locals who are as friendly as they are laid-back. The entire island is only about 70 square miles, but you can find a variety of beaches in Aruba, each with a unique character.
One in particular stands out from the pack, though. Eagle Beach faces west, meaning this is the spot for the best sunsets. Besides the pristine sand and tranquil water at Eagle Beach, there are also iconic fofoti trees (aka divi-divi trees) that are native to Aruba. These are low-growing and have the appearance of large bonsai trees, which is why so many people go to Eagle Beach to take photos of them!
Another huge plus for Aruba is that it’s a fantastic destination for solo female travelers. It’s a small island and known to be very safe, so exploring it on your own is a breeze. There’s a misconception that Aruba is merely a honeymoon island, but that couldn’t be further from the truth.
From rugged adventures like exploring Guadirikiri Cave and traversing Arikok National Park to hanging out with flamingos at Flamingo Beach, there is so much to do in Aruba for every kind of visitor. It’s no wonder why it’s such a popular destination for solo travelers.
- When to go: March is the busiest time on the island, so aim to visit between April and August, when there are fewer crowds and prices are lower. You’ll also have a better chance of missing hurricane season if you visit before August.
- Where to stay: This sweet ocean cabin is an incredible option that won’t break the bank.
2. The Bahamas
This archipelago nation is full of hidden gems and unique experiences. You can swim with pigs in the Exumas, snuggle up to nurse sharks, feed huge iguanas, and snorkel in the second-deepest blue hole on the planet, among other exciting things to do in the Bahamas.
From tourist hot spots like Paradise Island and the culture-rich capital city of Nassau to the glorious national parks and tiny pristine islands, there’s a variety of vibes in the Bahamas. You can escape to Bimini for a remote beach day or spend an afternoon hiking through caverns at Lucayan National Park.
If you want a relaxed, no-fuss trip, don’t pass up the opportunity to spend some time at Staniel Cay. This small island only has a couple hundred inhabitants and a down-to-earth atmosphere that feels worlds away from the big hotels on Paradise Island. Find out what to do in Staniel Cay in this complete guide.
- When to go: High season in the Bahamas is from mid-December to mid-April. During this time, you’ll have the absolute best weather, but prices are high and it’s crowded. Aim for the sweet spot: November and May. You might encounter some rain during these months, but prices will be lower.
- Where to stay: Consider staying at EMBRACE resort in Staniel Cay, which promises to immerse guests in Bahamian culture and hospitality.
3. Bonaire
Bonaire is a hidden Caribbean gem that deserves your attention. This small island – neighbor to larger Aruba and Curacao – offers an incredible tropical experience that leaves a lasting impression on all kinds of travelers.
Bonaire stands out as a destination that is both off-the-beaten path, but also so easy to visit and navigate. Unlike some remote destinations, reaching Bonaire is hassle-free, with a small international airport that ensures a swift customs clearance process. Within minutes of landing, you can be at your hotel, ready to start your adventure.
Bonaire’s underwater world is a paradise for snorkelers and scuba divers. The island’s marine park, protected since 1979, has some of the Caribbean’s most vibrant marine life. What sets Bonaire apart is that the coral reef starts right offshore, with many hotels offering their own “house reefs”; It’s a fantastic experience for snorkelers and divers of all levels of experience to really see the underwater world of the Caribbean.
The island also stands out for its quirky colorful vibe. While it’s not known for bustling nightlife, the island offers a delightful dining scene in downtown Kralendijk, where you can savor local cuisine. The atmosphere is relaxed, and you’ll find friendly locals (many of whom are Dutch). Settle in, stay a while, and spend the evenings chatting over a cocktail about what you saw underwater that day.
- When to Go: Bonaire is great anytime of the year! The ABC islands are outside of the Hurricane Belt, meaning you don’t have to limit your travels to high season (November to April). To be sure, the weather is delightful and sea conditions calm during this period, but you can visit Bonaire anytime of year.
- Where to Stay: Harbor Village Beach Club is hands-down the most comfortable and peaceful place to stay in Bonaire. The beachfront suites are spacious and comfortable, and the snorkeling right off the private beach phenomenal.
4. St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands
Although it’s the most densely populated and most visited of the US Virgin Islands, St. Thomas lives up to the hype with its postcard-perfect beaches and lush green mountain peaks. This tropical escape is especially ideal if you’re a US citizen, because you don’t need a passport to visit, and it’s a very short flight from Florida.
Whether your idea of appreciating nature involves lounging in a beach chair or climbing a mountain, there’s lots to adore here. Drive up to Drake’s Seat to get a panoramic view of the island, kayak through the mangroves at Cas Cay, or catch a sunrise at Sapphire Beach.
It’s time to start planning your St. Thomas itinerary!
- When to go: The best way to avoid a majority of the cruise ship madness is to visit St. Thomas between April and June, before the summer heat ramps up. It might be a bit more rainy during these months, but having fewer people at the beaches is definitely worth it.
- Where to stay: If you want to go for luxury, this king suite has incredible amenities and stunning views of Sapphire Beach.
5. St. John, US Virgin Islands
This small island packs a big punch and is perhaps the most underrated of the US Virgin Islands. About 60% is covered by Virgin Islands National Park, meaning you’ll find a virtually untouched natural wonderland there. Unlike St. Thomas, St. John has just one chain hotel; most visitors opt for more quaint options like bungalows or villas. Because the island is so small and most of the accommodations are perched high up on hilltops, many have astonishing views of the turquoise waters below. Hello, paradise!
In St. John you may want to rent some snorkel gear so you can check out the marine life at Maho Bay Beach, which is known for its sea turtles. If you’re down for a hike, consider the beloved Reef Bay Trail, which will take you to a remote beach in Reef Bay. It’s only five miles, out and back.
If you’re eager to check out Virgin Islands National Park, there’s plenty to do there. Popular activities include kayaking in Hurricane Hole, exploring the Annaberg Plantation Ruins, and of course hiking.
Read up on everything you need to know about visiting St. John here.
- When to go: April to May and September to October are the best months to go to St. John, because you’ll get shoulder season prices, plus the island is especially lush during these times. However, visiting in September or October means there is a risk of hurricanes.
- Where to stay: This gorgeous estate is located inside Virgin Islands National Park, and all rooms have a private patio.
6. Jost Van Dyke, British Virgin Islands
Jost Van Dyke, a jewel nestled in the British Virgin Islands, is the epitome of a secluded yet vibrant beach getaway. This charming island is celebrated for its pristine beaches, with White Bay Beach taking center stage. Jost Van Dyke is renowned for three compelling reasons, each of which contributes to its allure for the right traveler.
First and foremost, it’s home to the iconic Soggy Dollar Bar, a legendary beach bar known for crafting the Painkiller cocktail. Secondly, this island has achieved a level of “country music fame,” as it played a pivotal role in the lyrics of Kenny Chesney’s songs, who fell in love with Jost Van Dyke and immortalized it in his music. And third, White Bay Beach is absolutely breathtaking, exactly what many of us imagine when we picture the Caribbean island’s shores.
Jost Van Dyke is tailor-made for those seeking the quintessential experience in the Virgin Islands—a small island blessed with an absolutely breathtaking beach, boasting one of the most picturesque stretches of sand in the entire Caribbean. Even if you don’t spend your entire trip here, if you take a trip to any of the U.S. or British Virgin Islands, a day trip to Jost Van Dyke is a must.
- When to Go: Jost Van Dyke is best enjoyed during the dry season from December to April, but we would take the chance to go there any time of the year.
- Where to Stay: Jost Van Dyke introduced its first luxury villas in 2022 at the Hideout BVI – absolutely the place to stay for a few nights of luxury right on White Bay Beach.
7. St. Lucia
In many ways, the landscape on St. Lucia feels surreal. Lush rainforests in the island’s interior give way to volcanic-sand beaches with vibrant turquoise water. Off the coast are brightly colored coral reefs, as well as dolphins, whales, and so much more. And the whole island is a hotbed of geothermal activity to boot.
St. Lucia is also rich in culture and has a fascinating history. Having changed hands between Great Britain and France a handful of times, there are influences from both countries, as well as a strong Afro Caribbean culture that is present in everything from the gastronomy to the textiles.
From soaking in mineral-rich muddy water at Sulphur Springs for a natural spa treatment to climbing the steep mountain of Gros Piton, there’s plenty to do in St. Lucia to keep you busy as a solo traveler or otherwise.
- When to go: Like St. John, the best time to visit St. Lucia is from April to May. Rainfall is low, and when it does rain, it comes in short spurts. It’s not a very popular time to visit, so you’ll enjoy fewer crowds.
- Where to stay: This lookout spot not only has incredible views but it’s surrounded by nature and has a rugged vibe perfect for adventurous travelers. Here’s a listing of some of the best Honeymoon resorts as well.
8. Dominica
Dominica is the ultimate adventurer’s fantasy and perhaps the most rugged of the islands on this list. Thundering waterfalls carve out pristine pools in the lush green jungles of the island’s interior, making for a grand contrast with the black and silver volcanic-sand beaches. This isn’t a Caribbean island with the typical soft white sand, but it has its own beauty to behold.
A popular activity in Dominica is canyoning in the rainforest, where you’ll encounter deep gorges, impressive waterfalls, and pools that you can swim in. Don’t miss out on a visit to the Emerald Pool, where the waters are ideal to cool off in after a long, sweaty hike.
Another huge attraction is the diving. There are 20 species of whale that make their home near the coast of the island, so if you have your PADI certification, you’ll definitely not want to miss out on the chance to dive here.
- When to go: This is one of the islands that is totally fine to visit during peak season (October to June), because the cruise ships only dock in the capital city Roseau and the crowds stay there for the most part. If you venture to other parts of the island, you’ll still avoid most tourists.
- Where to stay: There are a ton of cool, eco-friendly options in Dominica on Airbnb; this one was my favorite because of its homey feel and jungle location.
9. Antigua and Barbuda
Antigua and Barbuda consists of three islands, actually, the third being a small uninhabited one called Redonda. Antigua is the largest and has the most to do, and Barbuda is full of natural beauty and wildlife. On both, there are large swaths of white-sand beaches and crystal-clear waters just right for wading, snorkeling, and diving.
One of the best beaches in Antigua is Half Moon Bay, which gets its name because of its shape and stark white sand. You can also learn about the country’s rich history at Nelson’s Dockyard, which is Antigua’s most prominent historic site. If you want to get a taste of the wild nature of this island nation, make sure to spend some time on Barbuda, where you’ll find rare birds and other wildlife.
Although Antigua is a top honeymoon spot, don’t let that deter you from traveling there solo. If you rent a car, you can easily traverse the island in its entirety, taking in the stunning views along the way. With a diverse landscape and so much to see, you’ll forget about the honeymooners at the big chain hotels.
- When to go: Low season in Antigua and Barbuda is from May to November, with hurricanes and heavy rains a possibility from September to November. For the best shot at good rates and weather with fewer crowds, book for stays from May to August.
- Where to stay: There are great options on Airbnb for spacious rental units, like this one with an incredible view.
10. Curaçao
Curaçao is part of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, which is evident in the pastel-colored buildings in the capital city of Willemstad. This combination of Dutch architecture and cacti-filled rolling hills on a tropical island might seem peculiar, but it’s what makes Curaçao unique and worth visiting. Plus, if you look at photos of the seas surrounding the island, you’ll notice vibrant hues ranging from turquoise to spearmint green.
Unlike many of the US Virgin Islands and others in the Caribbean, Curaçao doesn’t depend almost entirely on tourism. There are several other industries that thrive here, which means the island has a strong sense of identity and individuality. Because of this, it’s one of the most culturally rich islands in the Caribbean.
You’ll want to spend some time in the historic center of Willemstad, taking in the sights of the old town, which is now a UNESCO World Heritage Site. You also can’t miss spending some time on the island’s most beloved beach, Grote Knip, with its rocky cliffs on either side and fine white sand. All of Curaçao’s beaches are in cozy coves like this one, which I find especially charming.
Other popular activities here include cliff diving at Playa Forti, seeing blowholes at Shete Boca National Park, and hiking through Christoffel National Park.
- When to go: Because Curaçao is further south than the other islands on this list, it doesn’t suffer the wrath of hurricane season nearly as much. Visit between May and November during low season and you’ll enjoy lower prices, fewer crowds, and just the occasional rainstorm.
- Where to stay: Our top pick for Curaçao is Mondi Lodge, which has quaint bungalows with a true island feel. Plus, the rates are reasonable for the amount of space you’ll have.
11. Jamaica
This is the place to go if you want to fully immerse yourself in Caribbean culture. Although many visitors stick to the gigantic resorts of Montego Bay, there’s so much more to see. From the ivory sands of Seven Mile Beach to the jungles of Ocho Rios to the Negril Cliffs, Jamaica has plenty of gorgeous scenery to behold.
It’s also full of adventure to keep a solo traveler busy, from climbing to the top of Dunn’s River Falls to exploring a bioluminescent lagoon and the beautiful Blue Mountains.
Sure, chowing down on delicious jerk chicken and basking in the radiant Caribbean sun sounds like a dream, but Jamaica’s lush green interior is also worth exploring. You can also visit the birthplace of the “King of Reggae” Bob Marley in Nine Mile on this history-filled day trip and hum along to his songs as you explore the capital city of Kingston.
- When to go: Peak tourist season begins in mid-December, so the sweet spot is visiting in November, since hurricane season will have just ended. Another decent time to visit is late April and May, as the summertime crowds haven’t arrived yet.
- Where to stay: Forever Cottage is far from the crowds of Montego Bay, and is the best price you’ll find for a property just a minute’s walk from the beach. You’re welcome!
12. Grenada
Grenada is proof that the best islands in the Caribbean are so much more than beach destinations. Known as the Spice Isle, this volcanic island is booming with cultural, historical, and gastronomical richness. The capital city of St. George is a joy to explore, with its brightly colored buildings, hilltop views, and museums, such as the Grenada National Museum. Check out the main market, where you’ll immediately smell the luscious scent of vanilla pods and nutmeg wafting through the air. You can even get a closer look at how the spices are cultivated and prepared on a spice tour, if you fancy.
The adventure doesn’t stop in St. George, though. Head to Grand Etang National Park to see a large water-filled crater of an extinct volcano, along with the park’s famous mona monkeys. The island’s lush interior features several waterfalls that you won’t want to miss, such as the Seven Sisters and the Annandale Waterfall.
- When to go: May is a great time to visit Grenada, because peak season ends in April and it’s still relatively dry. November is also rather dry, with a low risk of hurricanes and reasonable prices.
- Where to stay: Laluna offers spectacular hospitality and is just two minutes from the beach. It’s a great option if you’re looking to pamper yourself.
13. Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico is another entry on this list that Americans don’t need a passport to visit. From colonial forts to world-famous surf spots to waterfall-filled jungles, the island has everything that makes the Caribbean such an attractive region.
You could spend your entire Puerto Rican vacation just enjoying the sights and sounds of the capital of San Juan. The colorful streets and pounding salsa music fill this city with life. You might never want to leave — and I wouldn’t blame you.
If you want to spend a day in the sand, head to Luquillo Beach for gorgeous seaside views. Looking for a bit of adventure? Go to El Yunque National forest to slide down a natural waterslide and hike through the jungle. You can also take a glass-bottom kayak to see a bioluminescent lagoon at night.
- When to go: Mid-April to early June is the best time to visit Puerto Rico, as the wintertime crowds will have subsided and the rainy season won’t be in full force yet.
- Where to stay: Casa Coral is a certified Travel Sustainable property and is just steps from Luquillo Beach. It has great reviews and is one of the most affordable beachfront stays you’ll find.
14. Saint Kitts and Nevis
If you’re seeking the best Caribbean island to visit for activities beyond the beach, Saint Kitts and Nevis should be at the top of your list. This captivating island offers a blend of history, adventure, and relaxation.
Saint Kitts is steeped in history, and it offers an array of land-based activities that seem endless. If you love a cool fort – or a stunning view – a visit to Brimstone Hill Fortress is a must. It’s arguably one of the Caribbean’s best forts, featuring a massive stone fortress with maze-like ramps and stairs.
Beyond the fort, Saint Kitts offers a ton of exciting activities. Start with the Saint Kitts scenic train—a three-hour journey that gives an overview of the island’s history and landscape. Or zipline through the jungle, go horseback riding on the beach, or ride an ATV through the rainforest.
Don’t forget about the second island in this dual-island nation: Nevis, birthplace of Alexander Hamilton (and home to a great tour all about his life!). Nevis – a no-stoplight piece of paradise – is the ultimate calm, Caribbean getaway, with a stunning white sand beach, and a volcanic peak rising from its interior. It’s worth a day trip, or a few nights of your stay.
- When to Go: Saint Kitts is a year-round destination, but the best time for families to visit is during the dry season from December to April, when the weather is pleasant and ideal for outdoor adventures.
- Where to Stay: The iconic Park Hyatt in Saint Kitts is the place to stay for a luxury resort on Saint Kitts. For the best luxury trip, though, split your stay between the Park Hyatt Saint Kitts and the Four Seasons Nevis, just a 10-minute boat ride across the channel.
If you’ve been dreaming of lazy beach days followed by exciting jungle adventures, it may be time to pack your bags and head to one of these incredible Caribbean islands. There’s so much more to do in this part of the world!
If you’ve been to any of these, which is your favorite?
Leave a Reply